Bust of Brutus by Michelangelo

Description

This is a plaster cast of a bust of Brutus by Michelangelo (1475–1564). The original was made after 1539 and is currently in Florence. While Michelangelo’s sculpture portrays the character of his subject by the skilful carving of marble, Shakespeare’s Brutus is shaped through the type and quality of the rhetorical language he is given.

How does Shakespeare portray Brutus through the use of rhetorical devices?

Actors and directors such as Orson Welles have felt that despite the title, Brutus is the real star of Julius Caesar. And perhaps rightly so – he has almost five times the number of lines. His most crucial speech comes at Caesar’s funeral. Up to this point, there has been a high proportion of verse spoken by the characters. Much of this is iambic pentameter, such as the memorable lines in which Caesar resolves to ignore warnings to the contrary and go to the Senate: ‘Cowards die many times before their deaths / The valiant never taste of death but once’ (2.2.31–37). Brutus, however, decides to deliver his speech in carefully measured prose: ‘Romans, countrymen and lovers, hear me for my cause and be silent, and that you may hear. Believe me for mine honour and have respect to mine honour, that you may believe’ (3.2.13–14).

Does this mean Brutus’s speech is unsophisticated?

No. The poet Cicero dedicated two books on rhetoric to the historical Brutus, and Shakespeare’s version also shows evidence of learning. The critic Jean Fuzier counted 30 different rhetorical figures in the speech. For the critic Garry Wells, it is ‘so overdone that it approaches what is comic elsewhere in Shakespeare’. Through his prose, Brutus is aiming at an unemotional reasonableness, and referring constantly to himself. It sounds very like he is reading a prepared piece rather than fully involving and invoking his audience. Despite all of this, his biggest mistake is to have allowed Antony to have spoken afterwards and subtly refute his arguments. Fuzier counted 36 rhetorical devices in his speech but, most importantly, they were better used, and delivered in verse rather than prose.

Full title:
Plaster Cast of Brutus after the marble original by Michelangelo
Created:
after 1539 (sculpted); c. 1864 (cast), Firenze (Florence)
Format:
Object
Creator:
Michelangelo di Lodovico Buonarroti Simoni, Stiattesi (Signor) (Maker)
Usage terms

© Victoria and Albert Museum, London

Held by
Victoria and Albert Museum
Shelfmark:
REPRO.1864-14

Related articles

What the Romans did for Shakespeare: Rome and Roman values in Shakespeare's plays

Article by:
Andrew Dickson
Themes:
Tragedies, Global Shakespeare

Andrew Dickson discusses the influence of classical civilisation and literature on Shakespeare, and the playwright's critique of Roman values in Antony and Cleopatra, Coriolanus and Julius Caesar.

Neoclassicism

Article by:
Andrew Macdonald-Brown
Themes:
Satire and humour, Language and ideas

Writers and craftsmen including Alexander Pope, John Dryden, Jonathan Swift and Josiah Wedgwood found inspiration in the classical period. Andrew Macdonald-Brown explores how their works adopted the style, genres, aesthetic values and subjects of Greek and Roman writers.

Republicanism and assassination in Julius Caesar

Article by:
Malcolm Hebron
Themes:
Tragedies, Power, politics and religion

Malcolm Hebron situates Julius Caesar in the context of Shakespeare's life and times, examining the contemporary political relevance of the play's themes of Republicanism and assassination. He explores the play's use of rhetoric and theatricality, and assesses its reception over the past 400 years.

Related collection items

Related works

Julius Caesar

Created by: William Shakespeare

Julius Caesar opens with the tribunes (the elected representatives of the people) reproaching the commoners for ...