Effective policies for innovation support
- Document type
- Corporate author(s)
- Economic & Social Research Council
- Date of publication
- 1 June 2013
- Evidence Briefings
- Small business & enterprise: the practicalities of running a small business and the theory of entrepreneurship, Trends: economic, social and technology trends affecting business
- Business and management
- Material type
Policy supporting business is rarely subjected to rigorous evaluation. As a result we have no reliable way of knowing if large sums of public money are being used effectively or wasted on initiatives which don’t work. Previously there has been remarkably little use of rigorous experiment design in industrial and innovation policy. While large amounts of public money are spent supporting businesses around the world, nobody knows whether it’s having any real impact. In stark contrast with fields like medicine, new approaches are introduced without testing. At a time when public resources are scarce it’s more important than ever that we find out what works and what doesn’t – and that principle should apply as much to business support as it does to programmes in healthcare or schools.
A Nesta report co-funded by the ESRC has used the ‘Creative Credits’ innovation scheme as a case to carry out a robust impact evaluation. In the scheme’s pilot in the Manchester City Region, 150 Creative Credits vouchers with a value of £4,000 were awarded to eligible SMEs to develop collaborative innovation projects with a creative business. The SMEs were required to contribute a further £1,000 of their own towards their project.
The evaluation showed that Creative Credits initially boosted innovation and sales growth in SMEs in the six months following completion of the scheme - but after a further six months these impacts were no longer statistically significant. This decrease in impact would have remained hidden with normal evaluation methods used by government, and indicates that randomised controlled trials should be used more widely in the evaluation of business support policies.
Related to Small business & enterprise: the practicalities of running a small business and the theory of entrepreneurship
Downloadable report aiming to explain why few startups scale
Downloadable report on the BEIS Business Support Evaluation framework
Downloadable report on consumer prepayments on retailer insolvency
Related to ESRC
This evidence briefing is based on a report produced by the What Works Centre for Local Economic Growth (WWG).The report presents a systematic review of business information, advice, and mentoring
This evidence briefing is based on a report published jointly by the Enterprise Research Centre (ERC), Goldman Sachs 10,000 Small Businesses, and the British Business Bank.The report shows that
This infrastructure evidence briefing is based on research by the iBUILD Infrastructure Research Centre.The UK’s infrastructure is amongst the most interconnected in the world and has a pressing
This infrastructure evidence briefing is based on a recent report prepared jointly by the iBUILD Infrastructure Research Centre and the International Centre for Infrastructure Futures.The report