Implementation of the right of disabled people to independent living: report, together with formal minutes

Document type
Report
Corporate author(s)
Great Britain. Parliament. Joint Committee on Human Rights
Publisher
TSO
Date of publication
1 March 2012
Series
House of Commons papers, session 2010/12; HC 1074
Subject(s)
Disabled people
Collection
Social welfare
Material type
Reports

Download (478KB )

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD, the Convention) is the newest treaty in the human rights framework, and was ratified by the UK in 2009. This Report examines the UK's implementation of the right to independent living for disabled people, as enshrined in Article 19 of the UNCRPD.

Despite the UK having ratified the UNCRPD, independent living does not currently exist as a freestanding, justiciable right in UK law. This Report argues that the existing matrix of human rights, equality and community care law, while instrumental in the protection and promotion of the right to independent living, is not sufficient. The right to independent living should be added as an outcome in any forthcoming Bill on adult social care in England.

It also recommends that all interested parties, governmental and non-governmental, immediately start work on assessing the need for and feasibility of free-standing legislation to give more concrete effect in UK law to the right to independent living. The Government should publish their assessment of the need for and desirability of such legislation in the light of the forthcoming first report of the UN Committee on Disabilities.

The Government have characterised the obligations assumed by under the Disabilities Convention as “soft law”. This Report regards this as indicative of an approach to the treaty which regards the rights it protects as being of less normative force than those contained in other human rights instruments. The UNCRPD is hard law, not soft law, and the Government should fulfil their obligations under the Convention on that basis, and counter any public perception that it is soft law.

While the report recognises the exceptional economic circumstances facing the UK, itconcludes that there is a risk of retrogression of the UK's obligations under Article 19 as a result of the cumulative impact of spending cuts and reforms. There has been particular concern about the effects of reductions in funding for local authorities, changes to Disability Living Allowance under the Welfare Reform Bill, caps on housing benefit and the closure of the Independent Living Fund, and the way in which these might interact to restrict enjoyment of the right to independent living.

Related to Disabled people

Mencap annual report 2017

This annual report includes information on all Mencap's achievements for 2017

Mencap social care assessments: what happens next

This factsheet is for adults with care needs and carers

Mencap employment support allowance: information on the work capability assessment

This factsheet provides information for disabled adults on how to prepare for a Work Capability Assessment

More items related to this subject

Related to TSO

BHS: First Report of the Work and Pensions Committee and Fourth Report of the Business, Innovation and Skills Committee of Session 2016-17. Report together with formal minutes relating to the report

BHS (British Home Stores), which was founded in 1928, was bought by Sir Philip Green in 2000. It became part of the Taveta group, which is ultimately controlled by Lady Green, in 2009. On 11 March 2015

A reconsideration of tax credit cuts: report, together with formal minutes relating to the report

The 2015 Summer Budget proposed draconian cuts to in-work tax credits in 2016-17. Even when combined with the welcome increase in the income tax personal allowance and the National Living Wage, these

Education, skills and productivity: commissioned research

The Education Committee and the Business, Innovation and Skills Committee agreed to carry out joint work on the contribution that education and skills make to productivity. In preparation for this work,

Welfare-to-work: report, together with formal minutes relating to the report

The Work Programme has streamlined the procurement of welfare-to-work, created a stable, GB-wide welfare-to-work infrastructure, and now produces a similar level of job outcomes for mainstream participants

More items related to this publisher