Letter from H G Wells about The Island of Dr. Moreau, from The Saturday Review


This letter from H G Wells to the editor of the Saturday Review  is a response to a review of The Island of Dr. Moreau which was published in the same magazine in April 1896. 

What did P Chalmers Mitchell say about the book that brought such a strong response from H G Wells? 

P Chalmers Mitchell starts by praising H G Wells’s earlier work, but then complains that in this novel he ‘has put out his talent to the most flagitious usury’; in other works, he disapproves of it. He complains strongly about the amount of blood, the description of pain (‘unworthy of restrained art’), and the relentless horror of the story. It was acceptable at that time for reviewers to tell the story, and Moreau’s death is mentioned, and the boat with the corpses which drifts onto the island. 

But mostly what annoys Mitchell is the science. Although he agrees that ‘there is scientific basis enough to form the plot of a story’, he refutes Wells’s claim, made in an afternote, that ‘the manufacture of monsters – and perhaps even quasi-human monsters – is within the possibilities of vivisection’. Mitchell states that ‘you can transfuse blood or graft skin from one man to another; but attempts to combine living material from different animals fail’. 

How did Wells respond? 

Wells points out the damage done to his reputation by the accusation of bad science – ‘the stigma of ignorance’ – but is able to call on the British Medical Journal report of a successful tissue graft between rabbit and man, published in October 1896. Mitchell responded by pointing out that this was not a graft of nervous tissue, any more than the use of catgut in surgery. And he pointed out the ‘huge advertisement my criticism seems to have given his book’.

Full title:
'Correspondence; The Island of Dr. Moreau'
7 November 1896, London
Periodical / Ephemera
The Saturday Review, H G Wells
Usage terms
Public Domain
Held by
British Library
1855-1938 LON LD58 NPL

Related articles

An introduction to The Island of Dr. Moreau: science, sensation and degeneration

Article by:
Roger Luckhurst
Fin de siècle, Visions of the future

Roger Luckhurst looks at H G Wells’s The Island of Dr. Moreau as a text that both provoked and explored feelings of disgust, reflecting late-Victorian questions and fears about vivisection, cannibalism and evolutionary degeneration.

H G Wells’s politics

Article by:
Matthew Taunton
Power and politics, Fin de siècle, Visions of the future

H G Wells was a committed socialist whose political writing influenced, among other things, the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Dr Matthew Taunton considers how Wells engaged with socialist ideas in his journalism, social commentary and fiction.

Related collection items

Related people

Related works

The Island of Dr. Moreau

Created by: H G Wells

A scientific romance by H G Wells (1866-1946), published in 1896. In 1895, Wells had written a paper on ‘The ...