Changing perspectives and new ideologies
- Article by: Louise Kimpton Nye
- Theme: About Spare Rib
Towards the end of the 1970s, the social, cultural and political climate in Britain was shifting. The early optimism of the Women’s Liberation Movement (WLM) gave way to fragmentation and the Movement as a coherent organised entity was now in decline. In spite of this, Spare Rib was firmly established as the voice of feminism and went on to document some key developments in the Movement over the ensuing decade.
The Women’s Liberation Movement had always been characterised by many different viewpoints, or ‘strands’ of feminism. Broadly, socialist feminists saw the oppression of women as part of a larger pattern of exploitation of labour that affects everyone involved in the capitalist system. They emphasised that capital social relations and the state maintain and perpetuate women’s oppression and that women’s liberation was tied in with that of other oppressed people, including men.
Radical feminists saw patriarchy and male supremacism as the problem. They wanted to overthrow patriarchy by opposing gender stereotypes and challenging the patriarchal basis of social and political structures. Until patriarchy was ended, they argued, women would not be liberated. Although radical feminists opposed patriarchy, they weren’t necessarily anti- men. They didn’t take the viewpoint that patriarchy and men were inseparable. Of course, many feminists saw themselves as just feminists, and many took on aspects of different strands of feminism. As with many movements that explore and challenge the political and cultural status quo, the WLM is a multi-faceted, complex phenomenon.
At the Women’s Liberation Conference in Birmingham in April 1978, fierce confrontations between feminists of differing perspectives signalled an ideological split in the Movement. A strand within the Movement known as revolutionary feminists dominated the plenary session with vociferous arguments that the main priority of the Women’s Movement should be to destroy male supremacy, which they believed to be the basis of women’s oppression. For them, it was essential that women cut themselves off from men completely. They saw male violence as a manifestation of male supremacy and the only way to overcome this, in their view, was to end patriarchy and for women to take control. Some extremely heated exchanges took place and Spare Rib received many letters about this (letters page: SR No 71; June 1978). A turning point in the trajectory of the Movement had been reached. While many smaller conferences took place throughout the 1980s, this was the last national Women’s Liberation Conference.
Spare Rib magazine issue 071
A forum of readers’ letters about the recent Women’s Liberation Conference.View images from this item (7)
Usage terms: Items 1, 2: Issue 71, pp 26-28 Alexandra Kollantai, by Alix Holt pp 40-41, Music review of the first women’s Jaxx festival by Val Wilmer; cartoon and illustrations;
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for these items. Please contact email@example.com with any information you have regarding these items. P 41 review of Patti Smith in concert by Pam Isherwood
Usage terms: © Pam Isherwood Creative Commons Non-Commercial Licence
Photograph of Patti Smith by David Hill
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for this item. Please contact firstname.lastname@example.org with any information you have regarding this item.
Around the late 1970s, early 1980s, campaigns for improvements in welfare, housing and other issues lost momentum and at a local level, many women’s centres closed down due to funding cutbacks. Many feminists who had been active in the movement up until this point were now frustrated that the bedrock of sexism still existed and that fundamental change was yet to be achieved. In an attempt to bring more organised clout to their struggles, some joined more organised political organisations such as the Labour Party and other left-wing groups like the Communist Party.
Feminists had never been a strictly homogeneous entity with common experiences, struggles and aims, but it’s fair to say that the perspective of white educated feminists dominated the first decade of the Women’s Liberation Movement. By the beginning of the 1980s this position was being actively challenged. Working class women, Black women, disabled women, Jewish women, younger, older and lesbian women began to speak out and organise themselves to challenge their own form of oppression. Some saw this as the playing out of the proliferation of identity politics and hierarchies of oppression and this led to great splits and rifts among feminists and within the Spare Rib collective itself.
In August 1982 the magazine published an interview with a Palestinian woman subtitled “If a woman calls herself a feminist she should consciously call herself Anti-Israeli." ('Women speak out against Zionism', August 1982, no.121 pp 22-23). The article prompted an angry response among readers who accused the magazine of taking an anti-Israeli and implicitly anti-Jewish stance ('About Anti-Semitism', Oct 1982 no. 123 pp 20-21; Editorial, Jan 1983, no. 126). By entering into more political debates and being outspoken on many events and issues, the magazine courted controversy which was to continue right through to its end in 1992.
Spare Rib magazine issue 121
Controversial article about feminism, anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism.View images from this item (2)
Usage terms: Issue 121, pp 22, 23 Women speak out against Zionism by Roisin Boyd
Usage terms: © Roisin Boyd Creative Commons Non-Commercial Licence
Spare Rib magazine issue 123
Article in which the London Jewish Lesbian Feminist Group write about their experiences of anti-Semitism.
Usage terms: Issue 123, pp 20, 21, About Anti-Semitism by Jenny Lovell; Linda Bellos; Lin Davidson; Hannah Aziz; Bev Gold; Lilian Mohin; Sarah, Elizabeth; Sheila Shulman
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for About Anti-Semitism. Please contact email@example.com with any information you have regarding this item.
Around this time, there were great internal struggles within the Spare Rib collective in what was, in many ways, a microcosm of conflicts happening in feminism generally. The collective members discussed, argued, cried and wrote about it all in the magazine. Accusations of racism, heterosexism, anti-semitism and of privilege abounded. In an article called 'Sisterhood… is plain sailing' (SR no. 132 July 1983 pp 24-27), the collective members outline their differing views on the topics raised by the article 'Women Speak out Against Zionism' (SR 121).
Spare Rib magazine issue 132
Editorial about the collective’s differing views about Zionism and anti-Zionism.View images from this item (4)
Usage terms: Issue 132, pp 24-27, Sisterhood is Plain Sailing: the collective’s thoughts on Zionism and anti-Zionism, by Spare Rib Collective
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for Sisterhood is plain sailing. Please contact firstname.lastname@example.org with any information you have regarding this item.
Committed to fighting oppression of all women, Spare Rib continued to document the struggles, discussions and debates conducted by diverse groups of women. The February 1982 editorial introduces a series of articles by Kum-Kum Bhavnani about racism in Britain and how this particularly affected Black women. This was a significant time for race politics in Britain: the Brixton riots had occurred in the summer of 1981 and the resulting Scarman report and Nationality Bill came in for some heavy criticism amidst calls of institutionalised racism and imperialism.
Spare Rib magazine issue 115
Editorial introducing a series of articles about racism in Britain.View images from this item (6)
Usage terms: Issue 115 pp 49- 52, Racist Acts by Kum Kum Bhavnani
Usage Terms: © Kum-Kum Bhavnani Creative Commons Non-Commercial Licence. Photographs: Racism and Seamen in Liverpool, by Picture Post; Nasira Begum by John Smith
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for these items. Please contact email@example.com with any information you have regarding these items.
Spare Rib started to explore the perspective of Black feminists in more detail around this time. It examined Black women’s experiences of institutions, such as the police and NHS, whose behaviour they experienced as inherently racist (Jan 1984, issue 138, p. 6). Examples of appalling human rights abuses against Black people were documented on the news and letters pages of the magazine, as were examples of police brutality. The collective was solid in its stance that racism is a feminist issue in a society where white upper and middle class men have the most power and Black women the least. They also looked more deeply at Black women’s experiences, giving voice to an emerging Black feminist identity.
Spare Rib magazine issue 138
Article about sexism and racism in the NHS.View images from this item (4)
Usage terms: Issue 138, pp 6-8, p 26, The Racist and Sexist Delivery of the National Health Service--The Experience of Black Women, by Protasia Torkington
Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for this item. Please contact firstname.lastname@example.org with any information you have regarding this item. Pp. 7, 8 photographs by Michael Ann Mullen
Usage terms: © Michael Ann Mullen Creative Commons Non-Commercial Licence.
Since its inception Spare Rib had been concerned with issues affecting Black women and women’s struggles around the world. The older collectives published reviews of Black women’s books and there were many internationalist articles. These included reports by Jenny Vaughan on the struggles of Central American women who, exhausted by their daily battles, were keen for her to tell their story. In late 1982 there was a shift in the make-up of the collective when Black women joined and a year later, in October 1983 (issue 135), these women had editorial control in what was a ‘Special Black Women’s Issue’ of the magazine. They describe the challenges faced when representing the diverse viewpoints of Black and third world women and refer to the changes to the collective since they joined as ‘painful’ (Editorial, Oct 1983, issue 135). Also in this edition, an Asian woman doctor talks about her experiences of racism and sexism as she trained to become a doctor in the NHS; three young Black feminists talk about their experiences of racism and sexism in the UK and the particular difficulties experienced by Black lesbians; other articles explore Black and third world women’s experiences around the world and there are reviews of books by Black lesbian feminist Audre Lorde and also of Alice Walker’s The Color Purple.
Spare Rib magazine issue 135
Editorial in a special Black women’s issue of Spare Rib, outlining the process of changing the collective to include Black women.View images from this item (2)
Spare Rib magazine issue 137
Editorial about the magazine’s increased coverage for and by Black and ‘Third World’ women.View images from this item (1)
By the end of 1983, Spare Rib’s engagement with Black women’s experience had really gained momentum. The editorial of the December 1983 edition (no 137) made it clear that Spare Rib was ‘no longer a white woman’s magazine’. While acknowledging that all issues are relevant to both Black and white women, the collective made a pledge to give exclusive space to Black/third world women. This was an interesting and enlightening time in terms of developments in Black feminism and the debates which divided and defined the Movement at this time played out on the letters pages of Spare Rib in the early 1980s.
Spare Rib magazine collective circa 1986
Photograph of the 1986 Spare Rib collective taken on the back fire stairs at the Spare Rib offices at Clerkenwell Close. Back row from left: Grace Evans, Andrea Stuart, Linda Kinneard, Susan Ardill, Barbara Norden. Front row from left: Marcel Farry, Elaine Frere Smith, Tatiana Wahbe.View images from this item (1)
Usage terms: Usage terms: We have been unable to locate the copyright holder for Spare Rib Collective 1986. Please contact email@example.com with any information you have regarding this item.
The text in this article is available under the Creative Commons License.