A woman wearing a scold's bridle, 1655

Description

The word ‘scold’ was used to define women – and, much more rarely, men – who disturbed their neighbours’ peace with gossiping, ‘chiding and scoulding’ or unruly behaviour.

This book describes the harsh punishments for so-called ‘scolds’ inflicted by local magistrates in 17th-century Newcastle. It includes a troubling description of the scold’s bridle or ‘branks’ – an instrument used to humiliate and inflict pain on such women.

Although their use was illegal, these devices were employed in Scotland and parts of England by a number of magistrates, around the 16th and 17th centuries.

What cruel punishments are described here?

Ralph Gardiner records how a witness saw Ann Bidlestone driven through the streets by an officer of Newcastle. He was ‘holding a rope in his hand’ attached to the scold’s bridle. The heavy iron ‘crown’ was ‘musled over the head and face’ with a sharp metal gag ‘forced into her mouth’ to restrain the tongue, driving ‘the blood out’ (pp. 110–11).

Gardiner also describes the ‘ducking stool’, the more official punishment for ‘scoulds’. The accused was tied to a stool and ‘Duckt over the head and ears into the water’ (p. 111).

‘The irksome brawling scold’ in The Taming of the Shrew

This was part of a wider cultural fear of witches, ‘shrews’, and other rebellious women, like Kate the ‘irksome brawling scold’ (1.2.187) in The Taming of the Shrew.

Importantly, however, Shakespeare’s Kate is never subjected to the scold’s bridle or ducking stool. Her husband uses other methods to ‘tame’ her ‘from a wild Kate’ to a ‘conformable … household Kate’ (2.1.277–78), perhaps making him seem less brutal.

What is this book by Ralph Gardiner?

England’s Grievance Discovered (1655) is a petition to Oliver Cromwell, the Protector of the Commonwealth, from the brewer Ralph Gardiner. Gardiner had been imprisoned by the city’s corporation for refusing to close his brewery in North Shields near Newcastle. While he was in gaol, Gardiner wrote this book, arguing that the Free Hostmen of Newcastle should relax their control over the trade of coal and other goods along the river.

Full title:
Englands grievance discovered in relation to the coal-trade. With the map of the River of Tine and situation of the town and corporation of Newcastle. The tyrannical oppression of those magistrates, their charters and grants, the several tryals, depositions, and judgements obtained against them
Published:
1655, London
Format:
Book / Quarto / Print / Illustration / Image
Creator:
Ralph Gardiner
Usage terms
Public Domain
Held by
British Library
Shelfmark:
1029.b.4.

Full catalogue details

Related articles

Power and gender in The Taming of the Shrew

Article by:
Rachel De Wachter
Themes:
Comedies, Power, politics and religion, Gender, sexuality, courtship and marriage

Does The Taming of the Shrew advocate sexual inequality or does it show and critique men’s attempts to subordinate women? Rachel De Wachter discusses how we should think about relations between the sexes in the play, and examines how writers, directors and actors have explored this question over the past four centuries.

Print and perception: The literary careers of Margaret Cavendish and Katherine Philips

Article by:
Tamara Tubb
Theme:
Gender and sexuality

Margaret Cavendish and Katherine Philips both wrote across a range of genres and achieved considerable success in their day. Tamara Tubb explores their different approaches to the difficulties of being a 17th-century female writer: Philips created a reserved and modest literary persona, presenting herself as the ideal woman of the time, while Cavendish openly challenged literary and feminine conventions.

Related collection items

Related works

The Taming of the Shrew

Created by: William Shakespeare

The Taming of the Shrew is thought to have been written between 1590 and 1592. It is a popular comedy, though its ...