Review of Emma in The Quarterly Review, 1815


This review of Jane Austen's novel Emma appeared anonymously in the October 1815 issue of the Quarterly Review. It is generally accepted to be by the Scottish novelist Sir Walter Scott (1771–1832), although some critics dispute this. The author of the review considers Sense and Sensibility and Pride and Prejudice as well as Emma, and uses them to discuss the state of the novel in the early 19th century. 

The Quarterly Review 

The Quarterly Review was a literary and political periodical founded by the publishing house John Murray, which also published Emma. This may be part of the reason why the Quarterly Review printed such a long and favourable review of Austen’s novel. 

What does the review say? 

The writer argues that Austen’s novels represent a new kind of fiction. Until the beginning of the 19th century, novels were chiefly interesting because of the extraordinary scenes, events and characters they portrayed. Such novels were highly dramatic and sentimental, and contained extremes of human behaviour and emotion. Austen’s novels, by contrast, describe events and characters that readers will recognise from their own experience. The reviewer suggests that it is hard to make such realistic depictions interesting, but that Austen succeeds, writing with ‘such spirit and originality, that [readers] will never miss the excitation which depends upon a narrative of uncommon events’.

Although the reviewer portrays Austen’s novels as part of a trend for more realistic and less romantic fiction, it is clear that he sees Austen as an original writer, and Emma, Sense and Sensibility and Pride and Prejudice as superior examples of this new kind of novel. 

The writer notes that Austen’s characters are middle-class rather than aristocratic, and that she describes them with great precision; he picks out Mr Collins and Mr Bennet from Pride and Prejudice as especially believable. He compares Austen’s writing to the Flemish school of painting, which was famous for showing ordinary individuals engaged in ordinary tasks.

Full title:
'ART. IX. Emma; a Novel'
October 1815, London
The Quartlerly Review
Usage terms
Public Domain
Held by
British Library

Full catalogue details

Related articles

Jane Austen: social realism and the novel

Article by:
Kathryn Sutherland
The novel 1780–1832

Jane Austen fills her novels with ordinary people, places and events, in stark contrast to other novels of the time. Professor Kathryn Sutherland considers the function of social realism in Austen’s work.

Related collection items

Related works

Pride and Prejudice

Created by: Jane Austen

During 1796–7 young Jane Austen (1775–1817) wrote First Impressions. Her early effort was rejected, but ...


Created by: Jane Austen

Jane Austen began writing Emma in 1814 and the novel was published in 1816. The book can be classed as a ...